Nick's Pizza

Nestled in the heart of Forest Hills, NY, Nick's Pizza stands out as a distinguished Italian restaurant and pizza haven that expertly marries traditional flavors with an inviting neighborhood charm. This is not just another slice joint—it's a culinary experience that honors quality and craftsmanship in every bite.

Specializing in thin, crispy crusts baked in an authentic oven style, Nick's Pizza offers an array of mouthwatering options that cater to classic Italian cravings and adventurous palates alike. Among the highlights, the Margherita Pizza Personal and the Meatball Pie shine brilliantly with fresh mozzarella, tangy tomato sauce, and homemade Italian sausage that bursts with flavor. Complement these with delightful starters like the Caprese Salad, rich with creamy mozzarella and ripe tomatoes, or the crisp Caesar Salad for a refreshing balance.

Dessert lovers will find joy in the decadent Juniors Cheesecake and the house-favorite Cannoli, which provide a perfect, sweet finish. Meanwhile, the robust coffee selection, including a smooth Cappuccino, adds that comforting touch every meal deserves.

The drink menu is thoughtfully curated for pairing, featuring an impressive variety of beers like the delicate Belgian Leffe Blonde and the flavorful Allagash White, as well as wines such as the vibrant Italian Chianti Classico and the crisp New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc. These carefully selected options elevate the dining experience, complementing every bite and bringing out nuanced flavors.

Nick's Pizza's dining atmosphere echoes the warmth and authenticity of a traditional Italian eatery, with cozy booths that invite you to linger and savor. Several customers have praised the family-friendly vibe and the spacious layout, which comfortably accommodates groups with strollers without feeling crowded. The service is attentive yet unobtrusive, making every visit feel personal and welcoming.

Regulars and first-timers alike rave about the quality of ingredients and the clarity of flavor in every pie. Edgard Aponte highlights the remarkable balance where “you were able to taste each ingredient,” while Seth Dean calls it the “best pizza in the neighborhood,” applauding the “old school pizza shop vibes” and comfortable seating. Even after a challenging fire, loyal patron James Valente commends how Nick's Pizza quickly recaptured its rhythm, reinforcing its reputation as a Queens staple. While some note the price reflects the premium quality and portion size, the consensus remains that every dollar is worth a memorable, expertly crafted pizza experience.

For anyone craving authentic Italian pizza in Forest Hills, Nick's Pizza promises a feast that delights the senses and delivers heartfelt, genuine flavors. From the first crisp bite to the last sweet morsel, it’s clear that here, pizza is treated not just as food, but as art.

Contact: 108-26 Ascan Ave, Forest Hills, NY 11375 | +1 718-263-1126